We Tried McDonald's Second Attempt at Michelin Burgers

By Matthew Bossons, May 11, 2017

1 0

'We Try It' is a regular series where we try the latest off-beat food and beverage offerings.

They’ve done it again, and by they, we mean McDonald’s and the almost-as-famous Michelin Guide – two culinary juggernauts whose names we thought we’d never hear in the same sentence. That is, until December of last year, when McDonald’s launched two specialty burgers endorsed by a two-star Michelin chef, Spain’s Ramón Freixa.

While we had mixed feelings after sampling last year’s Signature Sauce Bacon Burger and BBQ Pineapple Beef Burger, clearly the response was enough to coax ‘the powers that be’ at McDonald’s to give it another go. 

Being the culinary cosmonauts that we are, and obviously caring so deeply about our readers’ taste buds and overall health, we decided to sample these two new burgers and report back our findings.

Creamy Nuts and Steamed Egg Beef Burger

We-Tried-McDonald-s-Second-Attempt-at-Michelin-Star-Burgers-1.jpg

When we opened the box of the Creamy Nuts and Steamed Egg Beef Burger (RMB28), we were greeted by a sandwich that appeared to have been made with the same level of care afforded to a crash-test dummy. In short: the presentation was sloppy. 

Ingredient-wise, the burger is built with 100 percent beef (allegedly), a steamed egg reminiscent of what you’ll find in any McDonald’s breakfast sandwich, lettuce, onions, what tasted like Big Mac sauce and creamy peanut butter. 

We-Tried-McDonald-s-Second-Attempt-at-Michelin-Star-Burgers-2.jpg

Despite the burger looking like was made by Ryan Reynold's character in the film Waiting..., it actually was quite alright. The smooth, savory taste was pleasant to the palate and the addition of an egg to a McDonald’s meal served after 10am was strangely satisfying. 

Also, for those not in the know, peanut butter is probably the single greatest addition to a burger. (Pro tip: chop up jalapenos and mix them into your peanut butter before applying to your burger. It’s outstanding.)

Chipotle BBQ-Style Chicken Burger

We-Tried-McDonald-s-Second-Attempt-at-Michelin-Star-Burgers-4.jpg

Up next was the Chipotle BBQ-Style Chicken Burger (RMB28), which, thankfully, came out of the box with a better presentation than the first sandwich (albeit barely).

The burger comes with a dose of tangy chipotle sauce and chicken that appears to have been battered and fried – not barbecued, as the name suggests.

We-Tried-McDonald-s-Second-Attempt-at-Michelin-Star-Burgers-6.jpg

Other components include lettuce, tomatoes and bacon that looks like ham, all stuffed inside a hearty, seed-covered bun that was about an inch-and-a-half too long for its contents. 

This sandwich’s strongest points are undoubtedly its aesthetically-pleasing bun and the chipotle sauce – which was key in covering up the taste of undercooked bacon. Its weaknesses? Definitely the bacon (did we mention the sad bacon yet?) and the small portion of slightly-soggy chicken.  

We-Tried-McDonald-s-Second-Attempt-at-Michelin-Star-Burgers-7.jpg

If we had to recommend one of the new Michelin monstrosities, we’d have to jump behind the Creamy Nuts and Steamed Egg Beef Burger – which, although far from perfect, managed to at least execute the meat to bun ratio to an acceptable degree.

While browsing the McDonald’s menu we also noticed a couple other new(ish) additions, including Maple Syrup-Flavored Wings and Loaded Fries (French fries topped with BBQ and cheese sauces).

We-Tried-McDonald-s-Second-Attempt-at-Michelin-Star-Burgers-5.jpg

While we did not dabble with the presumably Canadian-inspired wings, we did order the Loaded Fries (RMB13) and can report that they’re terrible. If you are dead-set on giving these ‘failure fries’ a try, be forewarned: the cheese sauce is essentially watery Cheese Whiz and the BBQ sauce would not be welcome within 100 meters of any self-respecting person’s grill.

To wrap this up, we will give each item a ‘star’ rating (five being the highest) for your reference:

Creamy Nuts and Steamed Egg Beef Burger: 4 Stars
Chipotle BBQ-Style Chicken Burger: 2 Stars
Loaded Fries:6 Stars

For more 'We Try It,' click here.

more news

What 5 Shanghai Chefs Really Think of the 2018 Michelin Guide

The Michelin Guide Shanghai has dropped its 2018 selection, here's what the F&B community has to say about it.

We Tried McDonald's New Michelin Star Burgers

We tested those new Michelin burgers from McDonald's. But were we lovin' it?

Tai'an Table Forced to Close Two Days After Michelin Star Award

Just two days after receiving their first star...

30 Restaurants Got Michelin Stars in 2018 Shanghai Guide

The day of reckoning for Shanghai's chefs and restaurateurs is upon us. See which restaurants earned stars in the 2017 Shanghai Michelin Guide.

7 Shanghai Chefs Rage Against the Michelin Machine

WARNING: this post may contain expletives.

26 Restaurants Got Michelin Stars in First Shanghai Guide

The day of reckoning for Shanghai's chefs and restaurateurs is upon us.

It's Official: Michelin Guide Coming to Shanghai 2016

Representatives for the highly influential restaurant guide have confirmed that rumors for a 2016 Mainland debut are true.

Michelin Guide To Hit Shanghai in 2016?

The most prestigious restaurant guide is rumored to be coming to Shanghai in 2016, but is the city ready for the impact of the Michelin system?

0 User Comments

In Case You Missed It…

We're on WeChat!

Scan our QR Code at right or follow us at Thats_Shanghai for events, guides, giveaways and much more!

7 Days in Shanghai With thatsmags.com

Weekly updates to your email inbox every Wednesday

Subscribe

Download previous issues

Never miss an issue of That's Shanghai!

Visit the archives

Get the App. Your essential China city companion.