Vogue Instagram Post Sparks Chinese Beauty Debate Online

By Rakini Bergundy, March 11, 2019

0 0

On March 3, Vogue came under fire after posting a picture of Gao Qizhen, a Shanghai-born model, on Instagram. AsiaOne reported that because of her wide set eyes and lack of nosebridge, Chinese netizens feel confused as to why Vogue would choose to feature this model.

Following Vogue’s Instagram post, Weibo was flooded with comments about the stereotyping of Chinese people. One Weibo commenter posted, “No matter how I look at this, I still think Westerners are laughing at the Chinese ideal of beauty… Chinese people want to make a good showing [of beauty].” 

Image via @iDest/Weibo

One popular fashion blog on WeChat, called ‘Shiliupo Baogao’ (石榴婆报告), wrote that netizens were up in arms over how some Western fashion brands are ‘uglifying’ Chinese people through ‘beauty bullying,’ a form of discrimination where Westerners inflict their own ideas of beauty onto Chinese people. But the article then went on to defend this model as ‘exclusively Chinese’ and ask rhetorically, “Should this [advertisement] not be a good thing?” 

Gao knows her looks challenge the conventional standards of beauty. In February, she defended her looks in a Vogue article, saying “Anti is a word that applies perhaps as a negative thing in some fields, but in terms of fashion and modeling I think it challenges the norms of beauty and looks.”

A similar debate took place on February 15, when Zara posted a lipstick advertisement with model Li Jingwen sporting a very ‘natural’ look.

While the ad was meant to draw attention to the lipstick, the product largely went unnoticed. Instead, Chinese netizens were annoyed by the model’s freckles. Some Weibo users commented that not all Chinese women have freckles, and questioned why the fashion brand chose to feature this particular model.

These comments faced a huge backlash from other netizens who argued that beauty is in the eye of the beholder, the idea of beauty changes over time and that freckles may have once been thought of as an ugly feature, but not anymore.

Zara responsed by saying their models are not retouched and that the advertisment showed Li’s natural face. To see pictures of the controversial ad, watch the video below (VPN off):

READ MORE: Chinese Model Apologizes for Appearing in 'Racist' D&G Ad

[Cover image via Zara Online and @WhiteBazaar白集/Weibo]

more news

New Media Artist Aaajiao Talks to Us About His Creative Process

In this age of digital communication, questions about our use and growing dependence on technology have become more and more prevalent.

Bad Dog Owners May Soon Face Social Credit Point Deductions in Shanghai

Bad dog owners might soon see their social credit scores affected.

Several High-Fashion Brands Under Fire Over Major T-Shirt Errors

Versace, Coach and Givenchy all went viral on Weibo after releasing similar T-shirts with offensive design errors that undermine the ‘One China’ policy.

Over 25 Million Flights Blocked by China's Social Credit System This Year

The credit system continues to catch fare evaders and other miscreants.

Porn Fears Lead to Suspension of Chinese Weather Center's Weibo

National Meteorological Center's Weibo account was suspended after netizens misinterpreted its yellow rainstorm alert.

China Jobs: Teaching, Media, Business Development

A roundup of the latest employment opportunities around China.

Eating, Drinking on Beijing Metro Now Impacts Social Credit

Say goodbye to the hordes of all-day strivers catching up on their morning baozi on the way to the office.

0 User Comments

In Case You Missed It…

We're on WeChat!

Scan our QR Code at right or follow us at thatsonline for events, guides, giveaways and much more!

7 Days in China With thatsmags.com

Weekly updates to your email inbox every Wednesday


Download previous issues

Never miss an issue of That's Magazines!

Visit the archives

Get the App. Your essential China city companion.