Student Documentary About University Dorms Sparks Heated Debate Online

By Edoardo Donati Fogliazza, July 5, 2018

1 0

"One Country, Two Dorms" is the title of the short documentary that recently sparked a heated debate among both Chinese and foreign netizens. The 12-minute movie was shot by foreign student Futura Costaglione for a class assignment and discusses the differences in the living conditions of Chinese and expat students in Chinese universities.

It features interviews with 12 students – six Chinese locals and six expats – from Beijing and Lanzhou and includes some gritty shots that don’t leave viewers wondering where said differences might lie. 

The mini-documentary shows that while international students are assigned spacious double bedrooms, sometimes even equipped with a private bathroom, their Chinese counterparts have to stick to cramped six-person rooms (pictured above) and leave the building for as much as taking a shower. Costaglione also addresses the regulations, such as curfews and timed electricity cutoffs, that are in effect in Chinese dormitories while not being enforced in residences for foreigners.

Foreign student's spacious double room

Bathroom conditions for Chinese students (left) and foreigners (right)

Originally published on YouKu, the documentary found its way into Sina Weibo, where it was viewed more than 500,000 times as of June 28, and inspired a commentary by What’s on Weibo. Users of the platform commented extensively on the topic – some complained about unfair double standards, while others acknowledged the considerably higher prices expats are asked to pay for their stay at the campus. A parallel discussion began on Reddit, where the documentary had been reposted, this time involving more non-Chinese netizens that shared their views on the topic.

The Minister of Education Chen Baosheng made clear last year that China wants to surpass the United States as the world’s most attractive destination for higher education by 2049, as reported by China Daily. Indeed, China has been working hard in recent years to attract international students, with 440,000 recorded in 2016 – an 11.5% increase on the previous year. These efforts include increasing the coverage of government scholarships and providing a living environment that can match the one that expat students have left at home.

Although many comments on the video from online platforms make use of expressions like the popular chongyangmeiwai ("to revere everything foreign and to pander to overseas powers"), which addresses the perceived Chinese habit to indulge in adoration of foreign goods and people, the local interviewees in the viral videos do not seem to resent their current situation, hoping instead that foreign students always feel welcome in their homeland. 

The debate, though, remains open.

[Images by Futura Costaglione via Youku]

more news

How a Rigorous IB Education Comes to Life at SCIS

Find out how your child can thrive in a rigorous IB World school at SCIS.

WATCH: 'M on the Bund' Documentary Teaser Trailer

An ode to the one and only Michelle Garnaut.

How a Rigorous IB Education Comes to Life at SCIS

The better we can share an understanding of rigor, the better we partner to help students succeed.

3 Men Sentenced to Death for Murder of Nanjing Student

Three men have been sentenced to death in what has been called China's trial of the century.

Student Takes Gaokao Three Times, Turns Down Peking University Twice

Despite being offered a place at Peking University and an RMB2 million scholarship, a student in Guangdong has turned down the prestigious school twice.

Giving Our City the Gift of Life: Jiahui Blood Donation Campaign

This is the fourth consecutive year that Shanghai Jiahui International Hospital has held a blood donation campaign.

Shanghai Student Expelled After Drugging Woman’s Coffee

Man expelled from Shanghai International Studies University for adding taurine to women's coffee.

Student Fined Measly RMB500 for Filming Females on Toilet

The man's actions and the pitiful punishment stirred up anger amongst students and netizens.

0 User Comments

In Case You Missed It…

We're on WeChat!

Scan our QR Code at right or follow us at thatsonline for events, guides, giveaways and much more!

7 Days in China With

Weekly updates to your email inbox every Wednesday

Download previous issues

Never miss an issue of That's Magazines!

Visit the archives