Book Review: Maggie Shen King's An Excess Male

By Bailey Hu, November 3, 2017

0 0

Forget ‘leftover women.’ In the world of An Excess Male, it’s China’s vast number of unmarried men that’s the problem, resulting in a fundamental revamp of society.

In this alternate future, a massive, government-led feat of social engineering has created a new model for the nuclear family: the polyandrous marriage. Becoming a woman’s first, second or even third husband is a valuable prize for a bachelor, in the most literal sense: prospective grooms must pony up millions of yuan just to begin the matchmaking process, and hand over a sizable chunk of their life savings as dowry by the end.

With such formidable barriers, lesser concerns like love and free will tend to fall by the wayside – for both men and women.

Wu May-ling was only 16, for instance, when her parents married her off to two brothers, Hann and Xiong-xin, for a ‘record-setting’ sum. A sheltered upbringing, designed to mold her into a desirable wife, preceded life as a 22-year-old stay-at-home mom.

Lee Wei-guo is twice her age, and has worked hard all his life to save up for a dowry. Despite his optimistic outlook on life, he fears that Wu and her two husbands may be his last chance at familial bliss.

As we follow the story of Lee, Wu, Hann and Xiong-xin, author Maggie Shen King deftly paints a dark portrait of the future. But while her debut novel has generated comparisons to dystopian classic A Handmaid’s Tale, it’s nowhere near as bleak.

Part of the reason is that the story maintains a strong connection to China’s past and present. Despite its sci-fi twists and turns, the novel is full of eerily relevant moments – like viewing recent history in a funhouse mirror.

For instance, in an echo of the fines used to enforce the former one-child policy, ‘China First’ legislation offers tax breaks to couples who accept additional husbands. And at the time the novel takes place, the government is aiming to reverse a cultural preference for male offspring by mandating that children inherit their mothers’ surnames.

Just as in the real world, however, regulations don’t always work as planned: Lee notes that ‘the birth rate has skyrocketed in anticipation’ of the new legislation, and even China First policy may backfire by ultimately pushing men to look overseas for wives.

In an effort to maintain social unity, the Party falls back on old-school mentalities. China’s 40 million unmarried men, rebranded by government campaign as ‘The Bounty,’ are treated as anything but: males suspected of having mental handicaps are rendered sterile and institutionalized, lest they pass their genes on to the next generation. Openly gay men must label themselves ‘Willfully Sterile’ and are forbidden from starting families. Even married couples must bend to the Party’s will, with divorces all but impossible.

The tale of fear and repression that King spins does have some plot holes. For instance, with society supposedly overrun by ‘excess males,’ it seems counterproductive to discriminate against gay men, for pragmatic as well as moral reasons. And it’s not clear what action other countries’ governments are taking, if any, as China falls ever further down the totalitarian rabbit hole.

Still, King weaves an engaging story. As Lee’s relationships with Wu and her husbands deepen, we discover that their union is much more complicated than it looks, with each family member hiding their own secrets and agendas.

Against the backdrop of a repressive regime, the main characters’ chances of finding fulfillment – with love, companionship and family – seem slim. But that’s exactly why An Excess Male succeeds as a novel: while building up an intriguing world, it never loses sight of the poignant human story within.

An Excess Male is available on Amazon.

more news

This Day in History: Bloody Saturday, Shanghai's Darkest Day

New York Times bestselling author's new book on the 1937 Japanese bombing of the city.

Book Review: Justin Mitchell's Shenzhen Zen

"Life, Love and Misadventure in the Middle Kingdom."

Do Claims of 'Erasure' Taint a New Book on Leftover Women Beyond Repair?

We examine the work of Roseann Lake and Leta Hong-Fincher in the wake of a Twitter controversy about Lake's new book, Leftover in China.

Book Review: Johan Nylander's 'Shenzhen Superstars'

Swedish journalist Johan Nylander's explanation of "how China's smartest city is challenging Silicon Valley."

Koryo Tours' Nicholas Bonner on North Korea, His New Book & DPRK Knick-Knacks

Bonner sits down with Noelle Mateer to talk DPRK design, then guides us through his new book, Made in North Korea: Graphics From Everyday Life in The DPRK.

The 10 Best Chinese Films of 2017

From box office bombs to record-breaking blockbusters, it's been an eventful year for domestic films in China.

The 2017 China Arts & Entertainment Approval Matrix

In the spirit of New York Magazine's famous hierarchy of good and bad taste, we present our Arts 2017 Approval Matrix.

0 User Comments

In Case You Missed It…

We're on WeChat!

Scan our QR Code at right or follow us at ThatsSuzhou for events, guides, giveaways and much more!

7 Days in Suzhou With

Weekly updates to your email inbox every Wednesday


Download previous issues

Never miss an issue of That's Suzhou!

Visit the archives

Get the App. Your essential China city companion.